Login with username, password and session length
0 Members and 5 Guests are viewing this topic.
So then on the question... How would you define Self/Others(or Ti and Yong?) in Liu Yao context?And that would be different depending on the question, of course, but there have to be some general definition.
But the Sibling line will produce the Yong line(Si>Wei), so shouldn't it interact only with its original line and not with Ti as well?
If a line can only interact with the line it transforms from, or transforms into, then surely it is impossible for Three Way Combinations to happen?
If a line cannot bring itself its own misfortune when it runs counter to the goal that it transforms from, then surely it is impossible to go from a sure win situation to total loser?
If what you say is the case, the Self and Other line, when observed as the emotional state between the two as well as each others goals and desires, we can be certain that the guy that the girl may have interest in, will have ideas that slowly are at odds with the girl regarding a relationship; because Earth on the Other Line will cause issue for Water on the Self Line; resulting in becoming even furter from each other ideologically in terms of starting and maintaining a succesful relationship.
Why impossible?Original line still interacts, only the resulting line is empowering it instead of interacting with the other lines.
The running counter for Self and Other, so for Hai running counter to Wei turning to Si.I'm not sure what is running counter.Its connected to the Clash, right?So they run counter to each other because Wei(potentially having arc with Hai, even though controlling it), turns to Si and they are opposite.
But clash can mean they are going fast into each other and that is good for relationship?
A Three Way Combination necessitates the line that it transforms into, into becoming part of the Combination.If the line it transforms into, can only interact with the the line it transforms from and still complete the Combination, how can it not also interact with other lines?
2. If we take the line that a line transforms into as being able to interact with other lines, Si Fire will Clash with Hai Water on the Self Line.
The rules I worked with suggest we need 3 active lines(day/month branch also work) and we have three way combination.
Do I understand correctly that you are looking at the resulting lines as what is joining the combination?
And as its someone she potentially doesn't know, so not a lot of relations already to show on Others, its easy to look at it as the clash showing they are moving toward each other...
I hope that explains the other question parts you had, as each part on their own will have taken too long a post to reply to properly.I hope that explains the other question parts you had
Not quite. Amoung the other ways for the Three Way Combination is where "certain" moving lines and their transformed lines form that Combination only, and there are specific reasons for this particular case.Typically it is lines 1 with 3, or 4 with 6. The reasoning being they each represent Heaven and Earth between each Trigram, and Man with Space or Man with Time in the Hexagram.
The theory proposes, that a line that transforms into a line that is next to the original line it transforms from, may be linked, but only in parituclar questions.
1. The "Other" Line is important, as a relationship is more than just what you are after. It involves another person as well. Therefore you cannot just look at Officer Lines.