Login with username, password and session length
0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
ding ding xin xinwei wei chou chou decade-yi wei
But if the pillars are reverse, Yi Wei is in your natal, and Xin Chou is in your LP, then it is consider as fan yin.
They are different. According to the 60 pillars book, this type of configuration placed you in the position of control.
Quote from: JR on August 01, 2018, 03:20:04 PMding ding xin xinwei wei chou chou decade-yi weiIndeed, JR, in Mangpai Bazi, we don't use the follow type charts. If your chart was follow, then LP Yi Wei would not be reasonable as you said.LP Wei: 1) Wei has the same image as Ding, so it's the occurrence for Ding to control Xin. Of course there is a limitation from the natal chart, Xin cannot be controlled well, because Xin is too strong.2) Wei is naturally the "arrival" of Wei themselves (your Day and Hour Branches). So it's also the occurrence for Wei to control Chou. Of course there is a limitation from the natal chart, Chou cannot be controlled well, because Chou is very strong. So it's a reasonable LP all right, but not great.LP Bing Shen: Bing has a drawback, because Bing combines with Xin. The intention of the natal chart is to control Xin, so combination is against the intention of the natal chart. This is how Mangpai works, the luck pillars had better follow the original intention of the natal chart.
Quote from: JR on August 01, 2018, 03:20:04 PMding ding xin xinwei wei chou chou decade-yi weiIndeed, JR, in Mangpai Bazi, we don't use the follow type charts. If your chart was follow, then LP Yi Wei would not be reasonable as you said.LP Wei: 2) Wei is naturally the "arrival" of Wei themselves (your Day and Hour Branches). So it's also the occurrence for Wei to control Chou. Of course there is a limitation from the natal chart, Chou cannot be controlled well, because Chou is very strong. So it's a reasonable LP all right, but not great.
Hi JLim, why Chou is not the one who controls 2 Wei with the help of Chou in Year? Chou is stronger than Wei as in the season but 2 Wei are produced by 2 Ding.
Quote from: Miss A on August 27, 2018, 02:35:50 AMHi JLim, why Chou is not the one who controls 2 Wei with the help of Chou in Year? Chou is stronger than Wei as in the season but 2 Wei are produced by 2 Ding.It's because Ding Wei is Ti (body), and Xin Chou is Yong (use). And also because 2 Wei are produced by 2 Ding.
Yes, you're right the season (Month Branch) prevails. But in your chart, both sides of hot/dry elements and cold/wet elements are equally strong. None controls the other. In a controlling structure, a more auspicious chart is when one party controls the other.
but doesnt the clash further weaken ding?