Fivearts.org
General discussions => FREE Life Reading Request => Topic started by: MangpaiLover on July 20, 2023, 11:14:08 AM
-
BING JIA GUI GUI
YIN YIN HAI YOU
Current Decade
GENG SHEN
Previous Decade
XIN YOU
male.
Just want to check on the mangpai theory of the live
wood and the dead wood concepts for this chart.
Is it applicable to this chart?
There is also the YIN-HAI Combination for this chart.
is it considered to be work done?
-
That theory is applicable on all Wood DM's, and this chart is Jia Wood, so yes.
Yi-Hai combination is one of the work processes, correct.
-
That theory is applicable on all Wood DM's, and this chart is Jia Wood, so yes.
Yi-Hai combination is one of the work processes, correct.
another question, since this is live wood, metal cycle should be quite unfavourable is it true?
also,if it is live wood, is it still favourable to see cycle like JIA YIN and YI MAO?
-
Yes, generally so
-
Yes, generally so
METAL Cycle is Unfavourable and Wood cycle is Favourable?
What about Water cycle?
-
Yes, generally so
but wouldn't the water in the chart transform officer.
is there a theory for this for mangpai?
-
Water is good, while Wood depends.
Further analysis is needed. For example, Hai cycle is better than ZI cycle
Hai is the element that transforms You as Officer. This is a work process in Mangpai
-
Water is good, while Wood depends.
Further analysis is needed. For example, Hai cycle is better than ZI cycle
Hai is the element that transforms You as Officer. This is a work process in Mangpai
for this chart, the favourable god is the HAI and
GENG, XIN, SHEN AND YOU
are all negative since it is METAL GOD?
I wonder why it is negative. don't mind sharing?
-
Water is good, while Wood depends.
Further analysis is needed. For example, Hai cycle is better than ZI cycle
Hai is the element that transforms You as Officer. This is a work process in Mangpai
if it is Live wood with alot of water like this chart
and comparing it with another chart with not much water.
does it mean the one that has more water will be able to
transform officer much better? is there a mangpai theory behind this?
-
don't mind if anyone could answer my question.
I not too sure if all the details have been given.
I don't mind confirming chart history.
-
Yes, generally so
can i say or not say this is considered good grade?
Since YIN-HAI and YOU-HAI actually perform work in the chart?
based on the traditional bazi, it say no wealth mean cannot store money.
What is your view based on Mangpai?
-
based on the traditional bazi, it say no wealth mean cannot store money.
What is your view based on Mangpai?
In Mangpai, Bing as Output represents Wealth. Reasoning: Output is the element that produces Wealth.
No Wealth Star: it does not mean that Daymaster cannot store money.
Look at this: Evan Spiegel (SnapChat) (http://fivearts.org/index.php?topic=1054.msg8032#msg8032)
(http://fivearts.org/fileserver/images/2023/07/20/deleteme.jpg)
-
hope someone can provide advice
-
based on the traditional bazi, it say no wealth mean cannot store money.
What is your view based on Mangpai?
In Mangpai, Bing as Output represents Wealth. Reasoning: Output is the element that produces Wealth.
No Wealth Star: it does not mean that Daymaster cannot store money.
Look at this: Evan Spiegel (SnapChat) (http://fivearts.org/index.php?topic=1054.msg8032#msg8032)
(http://fivearts.org/fileserver/images/2023/07/20/deleteme.jpg)
In that case, my wealth is floating on the surface? is it correct to put it that way?