Both bazi Masters told me different elements are better for me

[Sy]

24 Aug 1997
3:54pm
Singapore

I did not convert the timing above to solar time.

I have a lot of earth in my chart. One bazi master told me wood element will be most beneficial for me, the other one said metal and water elements are more beneficial for me.

Which one is accurate? I’d really appreciate some help, thank you so much

[smsek]

The true solar time for 24 August 1997, 3:54 PM in Singapore is approximately 2:47 PM (14:47).

what is ur gender? male or female

[smsek]

i assume ur a male ===>Based on your provided birth details, converted to True Solar Time for Singapore, your Bazi chart is analyzed as follows:

Bazi Analysis Summary

• Date: August 24, 1997, 2:47 PM (True Solar Time)

• Location: Singapore

• Gender: Male

Four Pillars (八字):
•   Year Pillar: 丁丑 (Fire over Earth)

•   Month Pillar: 戊申 (Earth over Metal)

•   Day Pillar: 戊戌 (Earth over Earth) - This is you, the Day Master.

•   Hour Pillar: 己未 (Earth over Earth)

Your Day Master is 戊 (Wu) Earth, which represents you. You are like a mountain: stable, reliable, honest, and practical.

Analysis of Your Chart's Elemental Composition

Your chart is characterized by an extremely strong Earth element presence:
•   You have four Earth elements explicitly in the heavenly stems (年干丁, 月干戊, 日干戊, 时干己).

•   Your day branch (戌) and hour branch (未) are both solid Earth.

•   The year branch (丑) is also Earth.

This creates a configuration where the Earth energy is overwhelmingly dominant and "congested." This is a key point of contention between the two masters you consulted.

The Disagreement: Wood vs. Metal/Water Explained

Both masters are analyzing the same chart but are likely focusing on different classical concepts to resolve the elemental congestion.

1.  The Master who recommended Wood (木):
    ◦   Theory: This approach uses the concept of "官杀克制" (Restraint by the Officer/Star). Wood (甲/乙) acts as the "Officer" or "Killings" star which restrains, controls, and disciplines the excessive Earth. The idea is that strong discipline (Wood) can shape the mountain (You) into something useful and structured, preventing stubbornness and inertia. It's a direct method of control.

2.  The Master who recommended Metal (金) and Water (水):
    ◦   Theory: This is the more classical and generally accepted approach for your specific chart structure. It employs the concept of "食伤泄秀" (Draining via the Talent/Output Star).

    ◦   The excessive Earth energy needs an outlet. Metal (金) is your "Talent" or "Output" star. Using Metal is like giving your mountainous energy a purpose—to produce, create, and express itself (e.g., through speech, art, technical skills, business strategy). This drains the congested energy in a productive way.

    ◦   Water (水) is your "Wealth" star. Water is drained and absorbed by the strong Earth. Pursuing Water means pursuing wealth, projects, and opportunities. Your strong Earth (your capacity) can easily control and obtain this Wealth. However, Water also helps to "moisten" the Earth, making it more fertile and less stubborn.

Which is more accurate? For your specific chart, where Earth is not just strong but congested, the Metal and Water approach is typically more favorable and sustainable.

•   Why? Introducing Wood (the controlling element) into a field of extremely strong Earth can trigger conflict. It's like trying to plant small trees on a hard, rocky mountain—the trees might break (Wood is weak in your chart, present only as a hidden stem). This conflict can lead to frustration, arguments, and unpredictable setbacks.

•   Using Metal and Water, however, provides a release valve. It turns your inherent strength into productivity and wealth, reducing the tendency towards stubbornness without creating direct confrontation.

Your Favorable Elements & Guidance

•   Most Beneficial Elements: Metal (金) and Water (水).

•   Useful Element: Wood (木) can be used cautiously, but it is not your primary solution.

•   Least Favorable Element: Fire (火) or more Earth (土). Adding Fire (which creates more Earth) would worsen the congestion, making you more stubborn, isolated, and unable to see opportunities clearly.

How to Apply This in Life:

•   Career: Pursue fields related to Metal (Finance, Law, Engineering, Technology, Data Analysis, Surgery) and Water (Sales, Marketing, Logistics, Maritime, Tourism, Fluid Industries).

•   Environment: Prefer environments near water (rivers, sea) or in modern, metallic cities. The color white (Metal) and black/blue (Water) are beneficial.

•   Associates: People who are clever, communicative, and resourceful (Metal/Water traits) can be very helpful to you.

Current Luck Cycle (大运)

You are currently in the 乙巳 (Wood over Fire) great运 from ages 27-37.
•   This is a mixed cycle. The Wood (乙) on the surface seems helpful for career, but the Fire (巳) below feeds your Earth, making the core congestion issue stronger. This can be a period where career opportunities (乙) appear, but they may be harder to capitalize on due to internal stubbornness or increased pressure. It emphasizes the need to focus on the Metal and Water strategies to navigate this period effectively.

In conclusion, while Wood has a theoretical role, your path to balance and success is more effectively achieved through the intelligent application of Metal and Water elements.

[Sy]

The true solar time for 24 August 1997, 3:54 PM in Singapore is approximately 2:47 PM (14:47).

what is ur gender? male or female

Hi I’m female! I apologise I forgot to include it in the initial message. Does it change your analysis if im a female? Thank you so much for such a detailed analysis I really appreciate it!

After the differing opinions of the bazi masters, I tried to figure it out myself. I honestly thought wood element was more suitable for me? Since young I’ve told my mum that I loved visiting my grandma house at the east side of Singapore which is the wood element, while I stay at the west side. I always feel happy and comfortable when at the east side of Singapore. For a period of time years ago I suffered from insomnia and Constipation and after visiting Taiwan, both these ailments went away since the first day of the trip. If I’m not wrong, Taiwan is the wood element right? I’ve check the bazi charts of celebrities I used to like a lot and many of them have a lot of wood elements in their chart.

I’m not sure if my way of analysis works? For my career, I’m hoping it would be social work or a special needs teacher, and if I’m not wrong, isn’t that wood element too? And I really love cats, which are wood elements.

Unless I’m totally wrong about my life ? ):

[smsek]

Revised Bazi Analysis for Female Client

Thank you for the corrected information. The gender reversal changes the direction of your Luck Pillars (大运), which is a crucial update. Your intuition about your environment and experiences provides invaluable context. Let's reconcile the theory with your real-life feelings.

Your Corrected Bazi Chart & Luck Pillars:
•   Gender: Female

•   Year Pillar: 丁丑 (Yin Fire over Yin Earth) → This is a Yin Year.

•   Result: Your Luck Pillars progress in reverse order.

•   Current Great运 (大运): You are in the 辛亥 (Metal over Water) great运 from ages 26-35.

八字: 戊戌 (Earth) Day Master, born in the month of 申 (Metal). Your chart is overwhelmingly dominated by Earth elements, creating a "congested" energy that needs to be balanced.

Reconciling the Theory with Your Life Experiences

Your personal experiences are not wrong; they are the key to understanding your destiny. Your strong affinity for Wood elements makes perfect sense when we look deeper into your chart and your current life phase.

1.  The "Hidden" Wood in Your Chart: While your chart appears to have no Wood on the surface, the Hour Branch 未 (Earth) contains 乙 (Wood), 丁 (Fire), and 己 (Earth). This hidden乙 Wood is a part of your core structure. You are naturally drawn to it because it is an innate, albeit weak, part of your energy makeup. It's like a seed buried in a vast field, trying to grow.

2.  The Luck Pillar Explanation - You Were Right!
    ◦   Your previous great运, from ages 16-25, was 庚戌 (Metal over Earth). The strong Earth (戌) in this cycle worsened the congestion in your chart. This often leads to feelings of stagnation, stubbornness, and physical issues like constipation (a classic symptom of excessive, "dry" Earth).

    ◦   You are now in the 辛亥 (Metal over Water) great运 (ages 26-35).

        ▪   The 亥 Water in this pillar is a huge benefit. Water moistens your dry Earth, making it flexible and relieving the congestion. This is likely why your ailments cleared up during your trip—the movement (Metal) and change in environment (likely more humid or watery) activated this positive Water energy.

        ▪   Crucially, the亥 Water also contains甲 Wood (hidden stem). This means your current 10-year luck cycle is secretly infused with Wood energy. This is the primary reason you feel so happy and comfortable in the East (Wood) and in Taiwan (Wood). Your intuition is correctly sensing the beneficial energy of your current luck cycle.

Your Career Path and Love for Cats

Your chosen path is insightful:
•   Social work and special needs teaching are affiliated with Wood, representing growth, kindness, and education.

•   However, the motivation is pure Earth: to nurture, support, and provide stable ground for others to grow. You are not using Wood to control; you are using your Earth's innate nature to nurture Wood. This is a beautiful and correct expression of your chart.

•   Your love for cats (a Wood animal) aligns perfectly with the hidden Wood in your hour pillar and the Wood energy present in your current luck cycle.

Conclusion: Wood vs. Metal/Water

Both previous masters had a point, but your experience provides the final answer.

•   Theoretical Foundation: For your congested Earth chart, the most efficient and harmonious balance is achieved by draining the excess energy. This is done through Metal (your Output Star) and Water (your Wealth Star). Metal (申) is already strong in your month pillar, giving you natural talent for expression, analysis, and communication. Water provides a goal (wealth, projects) for your energy to absorb.

•   Your Practical Reality: You are currently in a Metal/Water (辛亥) luck cycle, which is highly beneficial. This cycle is also secretly providing you with Wood. Therefore, your attraction to Wood is correct and valid for your current life phase.

Your Favorable Elements & Guidance:

•   Primary Elements: Metal (金) and Water (水). These are your tools for success and balance. They allow your energy to flow.

•   Secondary Element: Wood (木). Thanks to your hidden stem and current luck cycle, you can healthily engage with Wood. It supports your noble career goals.

•   Avoid: Fire (火) and excessive Earth (土). These elements worsen congestion.

How to Move Forward:

1.  Embrace Your Current Cycle: You are in a very good 10-year period (辛亥运). This is a time for using your skills (Metal) to pursue opportunities (Water). You will naturally find yourself in environments that feel right.
2.  Combine the Elements: In your Wood-related career, incorporate Metal and Water. Use structured methods (Metal), data, and clear communication (Metal) and lead with compassion and fluidity (Water). This combination will prevent any potential conflict and make your work incredibly effective.
3.  Trust Your Intuition: Your feelings about places and careers are a powerful guide. They are helping you navigate your destiny. Your Bazi chart doesn't lock you into a path; it explains the energy you have, and you are clearly learning to work with it wisely.

In summary: You are not wrong. Your life experiences confirm the analysis. Your current luck cycle (Metal/Water with hidden Wood) is the reason you feel such a positive draw towards Wood elements, and it makes your career choice a wonderful fit.

[Sy]

Revised Bazi Analysis for Female Client

Thank you for the corrected information. The gender reversal changes the direction of your Luck Pillars (大运), which is a crucial update. Your intuition about your environment and experiences provides invaluable context. Let's reconcile the theory with your real-life feelings.

Your Corrected Bazi Chart & Luck Pillars:
•   Gender: Female

•   Year Pillar: 丁丑 (Yin Fire over Yin Earth) → This is a Yin Year.

•   Result: Your Luck Pillars progress in reverse order.

•   Current Great运 (大运): You are in the 辛亥 (Metal over Water) great运 from ages 26-35.

八字: 戊戌 (Earth) Day Master, born in the month of 申 (Metal). Your chart is overwhelmingly dominated by Earth elements, creating a "congested" energy that needs to be balanced.

Reconciling the Theory with Your Life Experiences

Your personal experiences are not wrong; they are the key to understanding your destiny. Your strong affinity for Wood elements makes perfect sense when we look deeper into your chart and your current life phase.

1.  The "Hidden" Wood in Your Chart: While your chart appears to have no Wood on the surface, the Hour Branch 未 (Earth) contains 乙 (Wood), 丁 (Fire), and 己 (Earth). This hidden乙 Wood is a part of your core structure. You are naturally drawn to it because it is an innate, albeit weak, part of your energy makeup. It's like a seed buried in a vast field, trying to grow.

2.  The Luck Pillar Explanation - You Were Right!
    ◦   Your previous great运, from ages 16-25, was 庚戌 (Metal over Earth). The strong Earth (戌) in this cycle worsened the congestion in your chart. This often leads to feelings of stagnation, stubbornness, and physical issues like constipation (a classic symptom of excessive, "dry" Earth).

    ◦   You are now in the 辛亥 (Metal over Water) great运 (ages 26-35).

        ▪   The 亥 Water in this pillar is a huge benefit. Water moistens your dry Earth, making it flexible and relieving the congestion. This is likely why your ailments cleared up during your trip—the movement (Metal) and change in environment (likely more humid or watery) activated this positive Water energy.

        ▪   Crucially, the亥 Water also contains甲 Wood (hidden stem). This means your current 10-year luck cycle is secretly infused with Wood energy. This is the primary reason you feel so happy and comfortable in the East (Wood) and in Taiwan (Wood). Your intuition is correctly sensing the beneficial energy of your current luck cycle.

Your Career Path and Love for Cats

Your chosen path is insightful:
•   Social work and special needs teaching are affiliated with Wood, representing growth, kindness, and education.

•   However, the motivation is pure Earth: to nurture, support, and provide stable ground for others to grow. You are not using Wood to control; you are using your Earth's innate nature to nurture Wood. This is a beautiful and correct expression of your chart.

•   Your love for cats (a Wood animal) aligns perfectly with the hidden Wood in your hour pillar and the Wood energy present in your current luck cycle.

Conclusion: Wood vs. Metal/Water

Both previous masters had a point, but your experience provides the final answer.

•   Theoretical Foundation: For your congested Earth chart, the most efficient and harmonious balance is achieved by draining the excess energy. This is done through Metal (your Output Star) and Water (your Wealth Star). Metal (申) is already strong in your month pillar, giving you natural talent for expression, analysis, and communication. Water provides a goal (wealth, projects) for your energy to absorb.

•   Your Practical Reality: You are currently in a Metal/Water (辛亥) luck cycle, which is highly beneficial. This cycle is also secretly providing you with Wood. Therefore, your attraction to Wood is correct and valid for your current life phase.

Your Favorable Elements & Guidance:

•   Primary Elements: Metal (金) and Water (水). These are your tools for success and balance. They allow your energy to flow.

•   Secondary Element: Wood (木). Thanks to your hidden stem and current luck cycle, you can healthily engage with Wood. It supports your noble career goals.

•   Avoid: Fire (火) and excessive Earth (土). These elements worsen congestion.

How to Move Forward:

1.  Embrace Your Current Cycle: You are in a very good 10-year period (辛亥运). This is a time for using your skills (Metal) to pursue opportunities (Water). You will naturally find yourself in environments that feel right.
2.  Combine the Elements: In your Wood-related career, incorporate Metal and Water. Use structured methods (Metal), data, and clear communication (Metal) and lead with compassion and fluidity (Water). This combination will prevent any potential conflict and make your work incredibly effective.
3.  Trust Your Intuition: Your feelings about places and careers are a powerful guide. They are helping you navigate your destiny. Your Bazi chart doesn't lock you into a path; it explains the energy you have, and you are clearly learning to work with it wisely.

In summary: You are not wrong. Your life experiences confirm the analysis. Your current luck cycle (Metal/Water with hidden Wood) is the reason you feel such a positive draw towards Wood elements, and it makes your career choice a wonderful fit.

Thank you so much! I appreciate your kindness and your thorough explanation. Thank you for validating my intuition too, I was so conflicted at first.

Does it make a difference if my love for the east side and positive experience in Taiwan and my love for the wood elements things occured even before my current 辛亥 luck pillar? For eg My Taiwan trip was at the end of December 2017 during 庚戌 luck pillar.

I was hoping wood element would be my primary beneficial element because I’ve already started buying a lot of green things 😅. If not, that’s too bad. I’ll take note of your analysis.

I’d also like to ask if stocks and cryptocurrency investment and trading is considered metal element? I’ve seen some websites saying it’s fire.

I apologise for asking so many questions. Thank you for helping out!

[smsek]

Of course! These are excellent questions that get into the finer details. Thank you for providing the specific timing; it allows for a much more precise analysis.

1. Why You Felt Drawn to Wood Before Your Current Luck Pillar

This is a fantastic observation and a very common point of confusion. Your positive experiences in the 庚戌 (Metal-Earth)运 can be explained by the annual luck pillars that were in effect during that time.

While your 10-Year Great运 provides the overarching theme, each year has its own energy that interacts with it.

•   Your Taiwan trip was at the end of December 2017. The Heavenly Stem for the year 2017 was 丁 (Fire), and the Earthly Branch was 酉 (Metal). This is the Fire Rooster year.

•   Crucially, the month of December falls in the 壬子 (Water-Rat) month.

So, while your 10-year pillar was 庚戌 (Metal-Earth), you were in a:
•   Year: 丁酉 (Fire-Metal)

•   Month: 壬子 (Water-Water)

Analysis:
The strong Water (壬子) energy of that month was the primary reason your physical ailments (constipation from dry Earth) cleared up. Water moistened the Earth, allowing for flow and movement.
The Fire (丁) year energy likely made you feel more motivated and active, but the Water month did the actual work of balancing your body.

Your attraction to Taiwan (Wood) is still linked to your hidden乙 Wood and the fact that Water (the beneficial element) nurtures Wood. You were subconsciously drawn to an environment where the Water/Wood energy was strong, which provided the relief you needed.

This confirms the theory: your primary relief came from the Water energy, not the Wood. Your affinity for the aesthetics of Wood (green, east) is valid, but the core functional balance is achieved through Metal and Water.

2. On Buying All The Green Things

Please don't feel it's "too bad"! This is not a case of one being "right" and the other "wrong." Think of it as a strategy:

•   Metal and Water are your tools for functional success and energy balance. They are the engine and the steering wheel.

•   Wood is the style, the interior, and the noble purpose of your journey. It's what makes you happy and aligns with your compassion.

Loving and surrounding yourself with Wood is perfectly fine because:
1.  It makes you happy, which is important.
2.  Your career is in a Wood field.
3.  Your current luck pillar (辛亥) has hidden Wood that you are resonating with.

The advice is simply to ensure you combine your Wood with your primary elements. Wear your green clothes, but add a white (Metal) necklace or a black (Water) bag. Live in the East, but choose a place near a river or with a view of the city (Metal). This layered approach is the most powerful.

3. Stocks, Crypto, and the Element Question

This is a classic debate with a logical answer.

•   Stocks and Cryptocurrency are primarily 金 (Metal).

    ◦   Reasoning: Metal represents precision, analysis, structure, algorithms, data, and execution. The entire foundation of trading is built on charts (data analysis), precise buy/sell orders, and structured financial systems—all core Metal traits.

•   Why some say it's 火 (Fire): Fire represents risk, speculation, intuition, and rapid movement. The volatility and speculative nature of the market is the Fire aspect. It's the gambling, "get-rich-quick" emotion that people bring to it.

Conclusion: The vehicle itself (the exchange, the data, the currency) is Metal. The way you use it can be either Metal (disciplined, analytical trading) or Fire (reckless, emotional gambling).

For you, with your strong Earth, engaging in the Metal aspect of trading (careful research, systematic investing) would be an excellent way to use your Talent (食伤) to pursue Wealth (财). The Fire aspect (speculative gambling) would add more stress and is not recommended.

Final Summary: Your intuition is a powerful guide to what you like, and the Bazi theory is a guide to what works most effectively for your core energy. They can and should work together. You are on the right path.

[Sy]

Of course! These are excellent questions that get into the finer details. Thank you for providing the specific timing; it allows for a much more precise analysis.

1. Why You Felt Drawn to Wood Before Your Current Luck Pillar

This is a fantastic observation and a very common point of confusion. Your positive experiences in the 庚戌 (Metal-Earth)运 can be explained by the annual luck pillars that were in effect during that time.

While your 10-Year Great运 provides the overarching theme, each year has its own energy that interacts with it.

•   Your Taiwan trip was at the end of December 2017. The Heavenly Stem for the year 2017 was 丁 (Fire), and the Earthly Branch was 酉 (Metal). This is the Fire Rooster year.

•   Crucially, the month of December falls in the 壬子 (Water-Rat) month.

So, while your 10-year pillar was 庚戌 (Metal-Earth), you were in a:
•   Year: 丁酉 (Fire-Metal)

•   Month: 壬子 (Water-Water)

Analysis:
The strong Water (壬子) energy of that month was the primary reason your physical ailments (constipation from dry Earth) cleared up. Water moistened the Earth, allowing for flow and movement.
The Fire (丁) year energy likely made you feel more motivated and active, but the Water month did the actual work of balancing your body.

Your attraction to Taiwan (Wood) is still linked to your hidden乙 Wood and the fact that Water (the beneficial element) nurtures Wood. You were subconsciously drawn to an environment where the Water/Wood energy was strong, which provided the relief you needed.

This confirms the theory: your primary relief came from the Water energy, not the Wood. Your affinity for the aesthetics of Wood (green, east) is valid, but the core functional balance is achieved through Metal and Water.

2. On Buying All The Green Things

Please don't feel it's "too bad"! This is not a case of one being "right" and the other "wrong." Think of it as a strategy:

•   Metal and Water are your tools for functional success and energy balance. They are the engine and the steering wheel.

•   Wood is the style, the interior, and the noble purpose of your journey. It's what makes you happy and aligns with your compassion.

Loving and surrounding yourself with Wood is perfectly fine because:
1.  It makes you happy, which is important.
2.  Your career is in a Wood field.
3.  Your current luck pillar (辛亥) has hidden Wood that you are resonating with.

The advice is simply to ensure you combine your Wood with your primary elements. Wear your green clothes, but add a white (Metal) necklace or a black (Water) bag. Live in the East, but choose a place near a river or with a view of the city (Metal). This layered approach is the most powerful.

3. Stocks, Crypto, and the Element Question

This is a classic debate with a logical answer.

•   Stocks and Cryptocurrency are primarily 金 (Metal).

    ◦   Reasoning: Metal represents precision, analysis, structure, algorithms, data, and execution. The entire foundation of trading is built on charts (data analysis), precise buy/sell orders, and structured financial systems—all core Metal traits.

•   Why some say it's 火 (Fire): Fire represents risk, speculation, intuition, and rapid movement. The volatility and speculative nature of the market is the Fire aspect. It's the gambling, "get-rich-quick" emotion that people bring to it.

Conclusion: The vehicle itself (the exchange, the data, the currency) is Metal. The way you use it can be either Metal (disciplined, analytical trading) or Fire (reckless, emotional gambling).

For you, with your strong Earth, engaging in the Metal aspect of trading (careful research, systematic investing) would be an excellent way to use your Talent (食伤) to pursue Wealth (财). The Fire aspect (speculative gambling) would add more stress and is not recommended.

Final Summary: Your intuition is a powerful guide to what you like, and the Bazi theory is a guide to what works most effectively for your core energy. They can and should work together. You are on the right path.

Ahh I see. Thank you so much for clarifying my doubts and the advices given I’ll definitely remember what you said. Many blessings to you!


There’s actually one more question I’d like to ask, which is about my father. However, if you don’t wish to answer anymore, that is fine too. You have done me a great deal of help which I’m very grateful for already


Male
31 May 1966
21:52 (not converted to solar time)
Singapore

He has been having some health issues for sometime now and I’m hoping to help him out with his bazi. Since 2014 started, many issues occurred. Insomnia, heart issues, bleeding disorder (thrombocytopenia), and he almost lost his vision in one eye as well. He is also bad tempered. Just this year his blood glucose started being slightly higher.

His chart has a lot of fire elements. May I know which elements are beneficial for him? I’m assuming water element is Beneficial for him because it controls fire. He himself also likes wearing the Color blue and black, bathes many times a day, enjoy taking walks especially close to bodies of water, and drinks lots of water.

His room is currently situated in the northwest direction (metal element) in our house. I’m thinking of changing his room to the one at the North direction (water element). Would this be suitable ?
Or is metal element good for him too?


Thank you so much once again

[smsek]

The true solar time for 31 May 1966, 21:52 in Singapore is approximately 9:20 PM (21:20).

[smsek]

Of course. It is very compassionate of you to seek ways to help your father. Based on the information provided (May 31, 1966, 9:52 PM in Singapore, converted to True Solar Time), here is an analysis of your father's Bazi chart and his health situation.

Bazi Analysis for Your Father

•   Date: May 31, 1966, 9:20 PM (True Solar Time)

•   Gender: Male

Four Pillars (八字):
•   Year Pillar: 丙午 (Fire over Fire)

•   Month Pillar: 癸巳 (Water over Fire)

•   Day Pillar: 庚寅 (Metal over Wood) - This is him, the Day Master.

•   Hour Pillar: 丁亥 (Fire over Water)

His Day Master is 庚 (Geng) Metal. This means his core essence is like a sharp metal instrument: resilient, sharp, and principled.

Analysis of His Chart's Elemental Composition

Your observation is absolutely correct. His chart is dominated by a very strong Fire element:
•   Year: Strong Fire (丙午)

•   Month Branch: Fire (巳)

•   Day Branch: Hidden Fire (寅 contains丙)

•   Hour Stem: Fire (丁)

This creates a powerful "Fire dominating the metal" (火旺克金) configuration. His Day Master (庚 Metal) is being excessively melted and weakened by the surrounding furnace of Fire. This elemental imbalance is the root cause of his health and temperament issues.

•   Health Correlation: In TCM and Bazi, Metal is associated with the lungs, respiratory system, and skin. It also controls the function of the Qi or energy. When Metal is weak, it cannot control the Wood element, which is associated with the liver. The liver stores blood and governs the smooth flow of Qi and emotions. The heart is directly affiliated with the Fire element.

•   Temperament: A person with excessive Fire attacking their Metal is often impatient, quick to anger, and frustrated (Fire traits), but internally feels weakened and unable to express it healthily (weak Metal).

The Health Issues Explained

The health problems you listed are a direct manifestation of this imbalance:

1.  Heart Issues & Insomnia: Directly related to the excessive Fire energy, which overheats the heart and mind, preventing rest.
2.  Bleeding Disorder (Thrombocytopenia): The Spleen (Earth) is responsible for "holding" blood. The excessive Fire produces too much Earth (Fire creates Earth), but this Earth is dry and cracked, unable to perform its function of containment. Furthermore, weak Metal cannot support the Water that nourishes Wood (Liver), which also manages blood storage.
3.  Vision Problems: The Liver (Wood) opens to the eyes. The raging Fire is burning and damaging the Wood, directly affecting eyesight.
4.  High Blood Glucose: This is a Spleen/Pancreas (Earth) function. The imbalance in the Earth element, caused by the excessive Fire, is a key factor.
5.  Bad Temper: This is the classic manifestation of excessive Fire and a constrained Liver (Wood).

Beneficial Elements & Guidance

Your intuition is once again excellent.

•   Most Beneficial Element: Water (水). This is his number one priority. Water controls the excessive Fire, cools the system down, and protects his weakened Metal Day Master. This is why he has a natural, instinctive attraction to water, the color blue/black, and bathing frequently. His body is craving what it needs most.

•   Useful Element: Earth (土). This is secondary. Earth can "drain" the excessive Fire (Fire produces Earth). However, it must be used carefully, as it can also block Water. The right kind of Earth (stable, mountain-like Earth, not dry desert Earth) can provide a buffer.

•   Avoid: Fire (火) and Wood (木). More Fire is disastrous. Wood (木) feeds the Fire, making it burn even hotter and worsening all his problems.

Answering Your Specific Questions

1. Is moving his room to the North (Water) suitable?
Yes, this is an excellent idea. The North direction is Water. Placing him in this sector of the house will help bathe his energy in a beneficial element 24/7. This is one of the best things you could do for him. Encourage the use of black, blue, and grey decor in that room. Artwork of oceans, rivers, or waterfalls would also be powerful.

2. Is Metal good for him too?
Metal is his "self" element, but it is weak. In his case, strengthening Metal directly is difficult because the surrounding Fire is so strong it would just melt any additional metal. The best strategy is to use Water to control the Fire first. Once the Fire is controlled, his inherent Metal will naturally strengthen itself. The Northwest (Metal) room is not as directly beneficial as the North (Water) room would be.

Critical Link: His Luck Pillar (大运)

His health crisis starting in 2014 is no coincidence. He was 48 years old in 2014.
•   His great运 from ages 44-53 is 戊戌 (Earth over Earth).

•   The 戌 Earth is a "fire reservoir" – it contains Fire and creates very dry, hot Earth.

This luck pillar poured gasoline on the fire of his innate chart. The dry Earth (戊戌) damaged his Water resource (癸 in his month pillar), removing the only check on the Fire. This is precisely why his most severe health problems emerged during this period.

He is currently in the 己亥 (Earth over Water)运 from ages 53-63.
•   The 亥 Water is a positive change and a lifesaver. It provides the Water he desperately needs.

•   However, the 己 Earth on top can muddy the water, meaning his recovery might have complications or require consistent effort.

Conclusion: Your father's innate instincts are correct. He needs Water. Moving him to the North room is a powerful and supportive action. Please continue to encourage his natural affinity for water-related activities. This is his path to better health and balance.

You are doing a wonderful thing by understanding his energy in such a deep way. My best wishes to you and your father.

[Sy]

Of course. It is very compassionate of you to seek ways to help your father. Based on the information provided (May 31, 1966, 9:52 PM in Singapore, converted to True Solar Time), here is an analysis of your father's Bazi chart and his health situation.

Bazi Analysis for Your Father

•   Date: May 31, 1966, 9:20 PM (True Solar Time)

•   Gender: Male

Four Pillars (八字):
•   Year Pillar: 丙午 (Fire over Fire)

•   Month Pillar: 癸巳 (Water over Fire)

•   Day Pillar: 庚寅 (Metal over Wood) - This is him, the Day Master.

•   Hour Pillar: 丁亥 (Fire over Water)

His Day Master is 庚 (Geng) Metal. This means his core essence is like a sharp metal instrument: resilient, sharp, and principled.

Analysis of His Chart's Elemental Composition

Your observation is absolutely correct. His chart is dominated by a very strong Fire element:
•   Year: Strong Fire (丙午)

•   Month Branch: Fire (巳)

•   Day Branch: Hidden Fire (寅 contains丙)

•   Hour Stem: Fire (丁)

This creates a powerful "Fire dominating the metal" (火旺克金) configuration. His Day Master (庚 Metal) is being excessively melted and weakened by the surrounding furnace of Fire. This elemental imbalance is the root cause of his health and temperament issues.

•   Health Correlation: In TCM and Bazi, Metal is associated with the lungs, respiratory system, and skin. It also controls the function of the Qi or energy. When Metal is weak, it cannot control the Wood element, which is associated with the liver. The liver stores blood and governs the smooth flow of Qi and emotions. The heart is directly affiliated with the Fire element.

•   Temperament: A person with excessive Fire attacking their Metal is often impatient, quick to anger, and frustrated (Fire traits), but internally feels weakened and unable to express it healthily (weak Metal).

The Health Issues Explained

The health problems you listed are a direct manifestation of this imbalance:

1.  Heart Issues & Insomnia: Directly related to the excessive Fire energy, which overheats the heart and mind, preventing rest.
2.  Bleeding Disorder (Thrombocytopenia): The Spleen (Earth) is responsible for "holding" blood. The excessive Fire produces too much Earth (Fire creates Earth), but this Earth is dry and cracked, unable to perform its function of containment. Furthermore, weak Metal cannot support the Water that nourishes Wood (Liver), which also manages blood storage.
3.  Vision Problems: The Liver (Wood) opens to the eyes. The raging Fire is burning and damaging the Wood, directly affecting eyesight.
4.  High Blood Glucose: This is a Spleen/Pancreas (Earth) function. The imbalance in the Earth element, caused by the excessive Fire, is a key factor.
5.  Bad Temper: This is the classic manifestation of excessive Fire and a constrained Liver (Wood).

Beneficial Elements & Guidance

Your intuition is once again excellent.

•   Most Beneficial Element: Water (水). This is his number one priority. Water controls the excessive Fire, cools the system down, and protects his weakened Metal Day Master. This is why he has a natural, instinctive attraction to water, the color blue/black, and bathing frequently. His body is craving what it needs most.

•   Useful Element: Earth (土). This is secondary. Earth can "drain" the excessive Fire (Fire produces Earth). However, it must be used carefully, as it can also block Water. The right kind of Earth (stable, mountain-like Earth, not dry desert Earth) can provide a buffer.

•   Avoid: Fire (火) and Wood (木). More Fire is disastrous. Wood (木) feeds the Fire, making it burn even hotter and worsening all his problems.

Answering Your Specific Questions

1. Is moving his room to the North (Water) suitable?
Yes, this is an excellent idea. The North direction is Water. Placing him in this sector of the house will help bathe his energy in a beneficial element 24/7. This is one of the best things you could do for him. Encourage the use of black, blue, and grey decor in that room. Artwork of oceans, rivers, or waterfalls would also be powerful.

2. Is Metal good for him too?
Metal is his "self" element, but it is weak. In his case, strengthening Metal directly is difficult because the surrounding Fire is so strong it would just melt any additional metal. The best strategy is to use Water to control the Fire first. Once the Fire is controlled, his inherent Metal will naturally strengthen itself. The Northwest (Metal) room is not as directly beneficial as the North (Water) room would be.

Critical Link: His Luck Pillar (大运)

His health crisis starting in 2014 is no coincidence. He was 48 years old in 2014.
•   His great运 from ages 44-53 is 戊戌 (Earth over Earth).

•   The 戌 Earth is a "fire reservoir" – it contains Fire and creates very dry, hot Earth.

This luck pillar poured gasoline on the fire of his innate chart. The dry Earth (戊戌) damaged his Water resource (癸 in his month pillar), removing the only check on the Fire. This is precisely why his most severe health problems emerged during this period.

He is currently in the 己亥 (Earth over Water)运 from ages 53-63.
•   The 亥 Water is a positive change and a lifesaver. It provides the Water he desperately needs.

•   However, the 己 Earth on top can muddy the water, meaning his recovery might have complications or require consistent effort.

Conclusion: Your father's innate instincts are correct. He needs Water. Moving him to the North room is a powerful and supportive action. Please continue to encourage his natural affinity for water-related activities. This is his path to better health and balance.

You are doing a wonderful thing by understanding his energy in such a deep way. My best wishes to you and your father.

Ahhh thank you so much (for the millionth time)! I’m not too sure if I can convince him to change rooms though but I’ll try.  This has been very helpful to me I really appreciate all the help and advices! ❤️

[Under10Gods]

Good day.

Yang metal is your best element. The time from 2011 to 2021 is one of the best possible pillars of luck in your life. Wood can be yang and yin. Yang wood harms you. Yin wood helps. You attribute positive aspects to the wrong objects. For example, yin metal harms you. As you can see in your life for the next five years. Such a time is coming for you according to your pillar of luck.

[Under10Gods]

How to check in practice which elements and colors are useful for you. And which are not.

https://fivearts.org/index.php?topic=1825.msg15450#msg15450

[coldpillow]

[Hidden post: You need reply to this topic to see it.]