According to the rules I'm familiar with Xu is active line.
Day Branch clashes it and Day Branch interacts with all lines...
However... That doesn't make it moving it makes it active. Active means it can produce/support/vitalize any other line. T
Yes, that's right! Xu becomes activated, therefore Xu can produce Shen. Shen is the Annoying God (Ji Shen), it's not auspicious when Ji Shen is strengthened. This is also another factor why the hexagram does not turn out well for the enquirer.
About the case... Jlim style of reading is very different then what I'm using, so I prefer not to participate... His forum after all, but it is very interesting to read these quizes, thank you for translation. : )
Different opinions are welcome, so you're welcome to participate, whether before or after the answer. The answer may not be as important as the discussion.
But actually, based on your last post, I don't see much difference between your analysis and what I use!
Topic: Quiz 3 - will i preserve my scholarly honor ? (Read 11293 times)