[Hidden post: You need login to forum to see it.]
Why is the setting flawed? At the time of casting my brother was already sick. The question was to confirm whether it would be covid-19 confirmed by PCR test. Two days after I asked, my brother took the PCR test and it was positive.
what is a gain hexagram?
I suspect that one of the Parents may reflect the "positive", either Zi or Hai, since L2 Hai moves secretly as a result of the branch of the day. Or maybe Zi is the positive and Hai is the immunity that favours the sibling (generating relationship). I thought about that before I cast, so it would be part of the setting one of the parents as immunity....
It would make sense to "win an officer" when the officer is sitting in the self line, but is sitting in the Other line. Wouldn't it make more sense for the officer to be in the self line so as to leave no room for doubt? ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
That is a very big misunderstanding that “ I thought about that before I cast, so it would be part of the setting one….” What you thought is not necessary to be followed if it is a flawed thinking. For example, I want to cook Chinese food. So I think to use soy sauce. Then I buy Japanese’s soy sauce and think that I already knew how to make the food. In fact, Chinese doesn’t use Japanese soy sauce. This is the flawed that you assume that you are right. as a result, the Chinese food is not really a Chinese food. And you think that you would already complete a Chinese food. So, with the seeking advice from universe. When “he” knows you are not right, how can he tell you that you are using wrong soy sauce when the universe can’t tell by words. So, your assumption make the whole situation in a different. Possibly chaotic hexagram. This is actually super common in I Ching text as well where reader not even realize that they have chaotic I Ching hexagram. (Text based)
In sickness question, matter element is officer, not sibling and it has nothing to do with parent that is immunity. Parent exhaust officer. You gotta think. How immunity can exhausted officer, which is the sickness in this case? So, you cannot explain in the way you think or assume you are right. In five element cycle, sickness being exhausted (parent) is not immune.
That is why as I said, when the logic is not making sense, this make the universe difficult to tell answer through hexagram. That is why this hexagram is already wrong at the first place. Imagine your grandchild ask you, “grandpa, should we let the chicken (pointing to rooster) lay an egg and eat the little chicken tomorrow.” Your grand child assume that every chicken can lay an egg, and he expected that the little chick will become immediately a big chicken that is ready to cook. This is all completely make no sense. And you will never give a direct answer to your grandchild. Or worst, you ignore them like how universe ignore you.
I think when it is wrong. It must has a reason. I see many learners suspect what is in the hexagram often end up in a wrong suspect. Most of the time, the suspect is not even closed to reality.