This is an excellent clarification! Thank you. Understanding that "Tientai" posted in the **Liu Yao forum folder** and is likely referring to **增刪卜易 (Zēngshān Bǔyì - ZSBY)** makes the search much more specific and relevant to traditional Chinese divination, rather than the danmei novel. My apologies for the initial misdirection; "Liu Yao" can indeed refer to both.
**增刪卜易 (ZSBY)** is a classic text on Liu Yao (六爻) divination, and you are correct that there are indeed various versions and editions floating around, some with different commentaries, annotations, or even minor textual variations.
Given that Tientai was sharing a link to his specific "Source of Wild Crane Studies" within the context of his "Liu Yao Case Studies" sub-folder on a forum, it strongly suggests he was either:
1. **Using a specific version of ZSBY that he considered foundational or particularly useful for his studies/interpretations.** The "Wild Crane Studies" might be his own personal notes, a compiled version of specific ZSBY sections he relies on, or a translation/interpretation he created.
2. **Referring to a *commentary on ZSBY* that he found particularly insightful.** Sometimes different schools or practitioners will have their own interpretations that become well-known.
3. **Using "Wild Crane" as a metaphorical title for his *own synthesis or unique approach* to Liu Yao divination based on ZSBY.** In Chinese classical texts, poetic or symbolic titles are common.
Since the original link is broken, and it was likely a personal upload or a less commonly known online resource, finding that *exact* version is challenging. However, here's how you can approach finding a suitable replacement or at least understand which version Tientai might have been using:
**Strategies to Identify Tientai's ZSBY Version/Source:**
1. **Check Archive.org (Wayback Machine):** This is your best first bet.
* Go to [https://archive.org/web/](
https://archive.org/web/)
* Enter the original broken link: `https://www.huliwenku.com/p/na4p3zdo.html`
* See if there are any archived snapshots of the page from 2018 or earlier. If you're lucky, the content might be preserved, or you might get clues about the specific edition.
2. **Contact Tientai Directly (if possible):** If Tientai is still active on that forum or has other online presence, the most direct way to get the information is to ask him directly which version of ZSBY he referenced for his "Source of Wild Crane Studies." He might even be able to provide a new link or share the material.
3. **Examine Tientai's Liu Yao Case Studies:** If Tientai's case studies sub-folder is still accessible, carefully read through some of his analyses. He might explicitly mention the edition or specific commentaries he uses for his interpretations. Look for:
* Direct citations or references to specific page numbers or chapter names.
* Any introductory remarks about his methodology or sources.
* Particular terminology or interpretive approaches that might distinguish one ZSBY lineage from another.
4. **Look for Well-Known ZSBY Editions and Commentaries:** While you have your preference, knowing the common editions might help you identify Tientai's. Some notable points about ZSBY:
* The original author is **Wang Hongxu (王洪緒)** from the Qing Dynasty.
* Many modern editions are based on the original woodblock prints.
* **Commentaries:** Some editions include extensive commentaries from later masters. These commentaries can significantly shape the interpretation.
* **Translations/Interpretations:** There are also various modern Chinese and English interpretations or summaries of ZSBY. "Wild Crane Studies" could refer to one of these.
You might look for common ZSBY editions published by reputable metaphysical publishers in Taiwan, Hong Kong, or mainland China, or English translations that are widely circulated within Liu Yao communities.
**Why "Wild Crane"?**
The term "Wild Crane" (野鶴 - Yě Hè) itself has significance in Chinese culture, often symbolizing longevity, reclusion, and connection to the Daoist immortals. It's also a common term associated with profound or esoteric knowledge. It's plausible that "Wild Crane Studies" was either:
* A poetic title for a particular interpretation or lineage of ZSBY.
* A direct reference to a master or school that used "Wild Crane" in their name or teachings.
* Tientai's own chosen "brand" for his in-depth studies.
Given your understanding of ZSBY, if you can access any of Tientai's existing case studies, comparing his interpretations with your preferred ZSBY version might give you clues about where his "Wild Crane Studies" diverges or aligns.
Good luck with your search!
